← The Galilee Review

Session notes

MZT session notes

Jonathan Zait

October 26, 2026

Israel/Palestine Research Forum – session with MZT, October 14

On a chilly fall evening, we had the pleasure of speaking with sociologist Michael Zanger-Tishler. Known among his peers as MZT, Michael, an esteemed member - and, in fact, one of the first - of the Israel/Palestine Research Forum, returned to the forum before embarking on his new path as an assistant professor at the University of Iowa. As more and more faces, familiar as well as new, poured into the room, the pressing silence was finally filled with the thing we had all convened here to discuss: the Lamas, aka the Israeli Central Bureau of Statistics.

The Lamas is an illuminating site where the very image that Israeli society - and those who study it - holds of itself and its social composition is shaped. In his paper, Michael masterfully demonstrated that these images, far from being determined solely at the primary level of data gathering, classification, and categorization, take their final form in the subsequent, secondary realm of scientific endeavor: namely, the part where these data are visualized and published. In other words, Michael asserts that we should also examine which parts of this knowledge become visible to the public, and in what ways.

Through his concept of “Selective Statistical Visibility,” Michael’s main contribution is a theorization of the varied ways in which state organs, such as the Lamas, can “distort” knowledge of populations: by aggregating data into novel group formations, thereby blurring social distinctions or highlighting desired ones; designing tables in ways that highlight facts considered worth mentioning; or completely excluding entire populations from a given study because of the potentially unflattering picture they might present. The case of the Lamas, aside from its significant role in the context of nation-building, provides an ideal example of such strategies, because existing archival documents allow the researcher to compare collected data with published material.

As soon as Michael’s compelling presentation ended, the room was filled with raised hands. The first half of the discussion was dedicated mainly to questions of particularity and relevance: What is peculiar about the Lamas, and which of its features exemplify universal, or at least common, characteristics that can be identified in parallel bureaucratic regimes in settler-colonial and post-colonial entities? A main point Michael made was that what is distinctive about the Israeli case is not only the complex configuration of Israeli society, but also the high visibility of the Jewish nation-state and the deep interest it attracted from the broader Jewish world, as well as from its Arab neighbors.

The second half of the discussion revolved mainly around questions of methodology and history. An essential factor in Michael’s reading of the many strategies employed by the Lamas to single out certain facts while marginalizing others is the idea that the organization’s goals ultimately reflect an Israeli/Zionist ideology: a coherent set of beliefs and preferences regarding what the Israeli population essentially is and how it should be governed accordingly. Finally, the question of how the relationship between the Lamas and Israel developed during the country’s early formative years brought us into a broader methodological inquiry into how scholars should understand the relationship between states and bureaucracies. Where, in other words, does Israel end and the Lamas begin?

When the clock struck 7:00 PM, a round of Lebanese arak, distributed among the room’s members, signaled that we should be starting to wrap things up. Yet, a frustrating halt is, for us, only a momentary pause in a never-ending conversation that will soon resume, and we hope to continue discussing Michael’s ideas also in our future sessions, which will all revolve around this year’s focus: professionals and technical mastery in Israel/Palestine.

MZT session notes · The Galilee Review · Israel/Palestine Research Forum