The Israel/Palestine Research Forum

Academic Year 2024–2025

Scholar-Activism

This coming year, the focus of the Israel/Palestine Research Forum will be to explore the multifaceted phenomenon of scholar-activism. We will examine the theoretical underpinnings, the motivations, and the rationale employed by Israel and Palestine academics who merge research and activism. In their role as experts, scholars have been successfully contributing to raising awareness on taboo issues, promoting agendas of social justice, and influencing policy makers. By becoming public intellectuals, they lowered the ivory tower and made research relevant to the communities they study. Rather than producing esoteric knowledge, the scholar-activist is assuming an active role in shaping the discourse, making an impact on people's lives.

Yet, their pursuit sometimes comes at a cost that blurs the lines between inquiry and advocacy. Both Israeli and Palestinian history are tainted with this ethical misconduct. Early Israeli historians created the building blocks for the understanding, justifying, and supporting the creating of the state – all the while Palestinian historians have laid the foundations for Palestinian national self-definition. Both camps were busy with nationalist rewriting of history and the affirmation of identity. In their mission, they sidelined crucial questions that challenged their agenda, and thus oversimplified history and downplayed the social processes that would present a different point of view. Concerns surrounding biases have clouded academic engagement, the core of scholarly thinking. Even though universities are considered to be open environments of intellectual freedom, academics who study and teach highly contentious issues, such as Israel/Palestine, are immediately seen as advocates, despite them questioning established assumptions, or offering alternative interpretations. Productive dialogue, where feedback and debate is encouraged, often is replaced by an endless battle of opinions and judgments, leading to the fortification of more and more echo chambers that celebrates self-indulgence.

Our forum will foreground a discussion regarding the influence of identity, background, ethnicity, or political views on scholar-activism. We will delve into the ethical considerations of representation and advocacy, to identify where advocacy encroaching on scholarly inquiry. And finally, we will consider the potential consequences for both academic institutions and the disciplines involved, such as the impact of scholar-activism on academic freedom, tenure politics, and the teaching and training future academics.

The Israel/Palestine Research Forum

Sessions that year

  • October 8

    Opening Discussion: Exploring Scholar-Activism and Defining Its Limits, Challenges, and Opportunities

    Dotan Greenvald and Matan Boord

  • November 1

    Biometric Statecraft, Policing, and Fingerprint Technology in Palestine/Israel, 1920–1948

    Michelle Spektor

  • November 22

    Academic Freedom and Freedom of Expression in the Field of Israel/Palestine: Between Neo-Liberal and Political Interventions

    Matan Boord

  • December 13

    The Evolution of Legal Culture: Mock Public Trials in the Mandate Period and Early Israel

    Dotan Greenvald

  • January 28

    Jewish Women Fighting for Social Justice on Both Sides of the Mediterranean: The Spanish Civil War and the Jewish-Palestinian Perspective

    Ra’anan Rein

  • February 18

    How to Dress in Palestine? German Jewish Migrant Experiences Between Nazi Persecution and Settlement in Mandatory Palestine

    Svenja Bethke

  • March 4

    The Inquiry-Centered Model: An Approach to Teaching Israel/Palestine in the Classroom

    Lauren Cohen Fisher

  • March 25

    War and Risk Preferences (joint work with Abigail Hurwitz)

    Ada González-Torres

  • April 9

    Passion and Palestine: Why Does the World Have Such an Intense Stake in Israel-Palestine?

    Derek Penslar

  • April 22

    Transgender Identity, Belonging, and Politics in the 1970s: Reading through Hahatakh (The Cut)

    Iris Rachamimov