The Israel/Palestine Research Forum

Academic Year 2026–2027

Islands of Expertise

Professionals, Craft, and Power in Israel and Palestine

Every profession is a bounded field: a domain with its own criteria of excellence, its own hierarchies of competence, and its own currency of prestige. The teacher’s pedagogy, the doctor’s diagnostic judgment, the lawyer’s command of procedure and negotiation, the rabbi’s, qadi’s, or priest’s mastery of text and precedent, the shepherd’s read of terrain and weather — each is forged out of the specific necessities of its craft, and each is largely illegible to outsiders. These are not isolated skill-sets but adjoining domains: islands of knowledge with their own depth, linked to one another by narrow but consequential nodes of contact.

In postcolonial societies, moreover, expertise often acquires a powerful political aura. The promise of national self-determination is bound to faith in technical planning on a grand scale and to a cult of the professions imagined to embody the knowledge, skills, and devotion required for state-building. In Israel and Palestine, the engineer joins the farmer and the warrior as a celebrated national figure, instrumental in the transformation of a colonized society into a sovereign political entity.

Israel and Palestine therefore offer an unusually dense laboratory for observing how these islands interact to make up a society and its politics. Skills developed for one domain routinely migrate into another, converting technical mastery into social and political capital along the way. Militants become ministers and heads of state; engineers become the technocratic backbone of settlement and state-building; philosophers become ideologues who shape the doctrines of national movements; merchants become the financiers and patrons behind political movements. Each crossing raises the question of what, exactly, is being transferred — the skill itself, or the prestige and legitimacy that mastery of a craft confers, now redeployed in an unfamiliar arena.

These transfers are never neutral. Professions generate their own social circles — guilds, associations, networks, sects of the initiated — that accumulate and leverage collective power well beyond any individual’s expertise. And prestige rarely tracks technical difficulty or social value in any simple way: the farmer, tilling the land, is often romanticized as a national archetype even where the craft itself carries little material reward or political weight, while a graphic designer can command outsized prestige. A craft’s social standing, in other words, is not fixed — it can hold steady for generations in one society while eroding within a decade in another.

Each island also has an inner life. Mastery is transmitted and certified in ways particular to the craft — the housewife’s knowledge passed from mother to daughter, the militant bootcamp training and trial by fire, the self-taught rigor of a tech field with no guild at all — and each community of practice argues internally over the ethics of the field, what counts as competence or a legitimate ruling. These internal cultures are rarely settled: a profession’s public face of consensus often conceals real contests over who is admitted to its inner circle and whose judgment ultimately counts.

This year, the Forum will ask where these professional islands overlap and where they remain stubbornly separate; how skills and forms of authority translate — or fail to translate — across domains; what mechanisms of social ranking attach to different crafts, and how those rankings shift across generations and societies; and what happens when a profession’s internal ethic — medical neutrality, legal procedure, pedagogical impartiality — collides with the demands of communal or national loyalty in a zone of protracted conflict. We will also ask what cultural products each profession generates — the city planner blueprint, the cartographer’s map, the chef’s table, the construction worker’s labor — and how far their influence travels beyond the guild that produced them. And we will ask a more speculative question: does craft-based expertise offer a form of legitimacy and connection that can survive, or even bridge, the region’s deeper political ruptures, or does it merely provide new vocabulary for the same old hierarchies?

We invite scholars of Israel and Palestine — sociologists, historians, anthropologists of everyday work, political scientists of elite formation — to workshop, read, and debate what the region looks like when viewed not through its familiar categories of nation, religion, or ideology, but through the granular, often invisible expertise of those who keep its schools, hospitals, courts, farms, and parliaments running.

The Israel/Palestine Research Forum

Sessions that year

  • September 16

    Planning without Hope

    Noam Leshem

  • October 14

    The Choice of Selective Statistical Visibility: The Case of The Israeli Central Bureau of Statistics (1950-1964)

    Michael Zanger-Tishler

  • November 11

    Post (Israeli) Election Analysis

    Eran Schwartz, Noa Balf, Adi Mahalel & Anwar Mhajne